Comparing Online Synchronous and In-Person Motivational Interviewing Instruction: Learning Outcomes, Preferences, and Satisfaction Among Public Health Professionals
Mary E. Larson & Shannon David · 2025 · Journal of Public Health Issues and Practices · Open access
Motivational interviewing (MI) is an evidence based communication method used by public health professionals to promote health behavior change. Traditionally, MI instructors used in person pedagogical methods for training learners, but geographical disparities necessitated the development of distance learning, and the SARS‐CoV‐2 pandemic further motivated a shift to online, virtual pedagogical methods. This study evaluated the feasibility and acceptability of online synchronous versus in person pedagogical methods for MI instruction among public health professionals.Forty professionals were randomly assigned to an online synchronous or in-person MI training group. Both groups received 14 hours of training from the same instructor using an identical curriculum. A mixed-method evaluation approach was used to measure the learning and acceptability of the training. Attrition following randomization led to participant dropout. Participants (n=16) submitted a recorded MI session for evaluation by trained MI coders using the Motivational Interviewing Treatment Integrity 4.2.1 (MITI 4.2.1) instrument were included in the analysis to determine MI skill and spirit competence. Pre- and post-training surveys were used to evaluate training preferences and satisfaction.MITI 4.2.1 global rating scores did not differ significantly between the two training modalities. The only behavioral count that differed was "giving information," which was statistically higher in the online group. Overall satisfaction was significantly greater among the in-person training group. Participants also expressed a stronger preference for in-person MI training. Several participants dropped out of the study, especially among the participants assigned to the online group, which impacted the robustness of the results.Maintaining fidelity is crucial when delivering evidence-based training. While online synchronous and in-person MI training pedagogy produced similar MITI 4.2.1 outcomes, participants were more satisfied with and preferred the in-person pedagogical approach. These findings support the feasibility of using synchronous online MI training methods to produce acceptable training outcomes for geographically remote participants.